NGO Another Way (Stichting Bakens Verzet), 1018 AM Amsterdam, Netherlands.

SELF-FINANCING, ECOLOGICAL, SUSTAINABLE, LOCAL INTEGRATED DEVELOPMENT PROJECTS FOR THE WORLD’S POOR

 

Homepage

Projects, examples

WRITE AN INTEGRATED DEVELOPMENT PROJECT

FREE E-COURSE FOR DIPLOMA IN INTEGRATED DEVELOPMENT

Articles and resources 

  About Us  

Downloads 

More on development issues

Some useful technologies

   Contact us

 

Edition 02 :  13 November, 2009.

Edition 05 : 09 February, 2013.

 

(VERSION EN FRANÇAIS PAS DISPONIBLE)

 

Summaries of monetary reform papers by L.F. Manning published at http://www.integrateddevelopment.org.

 

NEW Capital is debt.

 

NEW Comments on the IMF (Benes and Kumhof) paper “The Chicago Plan Revisited”.

 

DNA of the debt-based economy.

General summary of all papers published.(Revised edition).

How to create stable financial systems in four complementary steps. (Revised edition).

How to introduce an e-money financed virtual minimum wage system in New Zealand. (Revised edition) .

How to introduce a guaranteed minimum income in New Zealand. (Revised edition).

Interest-bearing debt system and its economic impacts. (Revised edition).

Manifesto of 95 principles of the debt-based economy.

The Manning plan for permanent debt reduction in the national economy.

Missing links between growth, saving, deposits and GDP.

Savings Myth. (Revised edition).

Unified text of the manifesto of the debt-based economy.

Using a foreign transactions surcharge (FTS) to manage the exchange rate.

 

 

(The following items have not been revised. They show the historic development of the work. )

 

Financial system mechanics explained for the first time. “The Ripple Starts Here.”

Short summary of the paper The Ripple Starts Here.

Financial system mechanics: Power-point presentation. 

 

 

SUMMARY   "THE RIPPLE STARTS HERE"

1694-2009: FINISHING THE PAST

Paper presented at the 50th Anniversary Conference New Zealand  Association of Economists (NZAE)  2nd July, 2009

by Lowell Manning.

..............................................................

"The Ripple Starts Here"  revises the Fisher Equation of Exchange first  put forward by Irving Fisher in 1911.

The original Fisher equation said simply that the amount of money M  in circulation times  its speed of circulation V must equal the gross  Domestic Product PQ where  P is the overall price level and Q the  total volume of goods and services produced.

MV  = PQ

In Irving Fisher's time his equation could not be easily checked  because much of the information needed to do so was unavailable.

He spent a good deal of his subsequent career developing indices and  associated data bases to better measure the economy.

In Fisher's day most economic transactions contributing to the  economy were still made in cash and his equation took no account of  either  Domestic or foreign debt.  These days in "modern" developed  economies almost all transactions are debt based and cash is all but  irrelevant.

****************************************

The debt model presented in the paper changes Irving Fisher's  equation  to a debt-based equivalent;
                                                                      

MdVp  = PQ  +  (Ms + Mv)Vp

Where Md is the total debt in the economy  (each dollar of debt is a  dollar of money somewhere), Vp is the speed of the productive debt 
giving rise to PQ, Ms  is the accumulated unearned interest on all bank deposits, and Mv  is debt borrowed for speculation.

In the debt model Vp must be 1, because debt can only be spent once. The model can be visualised as millions of separate transactions 
where the money to produce the goods and services is borrowed during  the production phase  and then repaid when the product is consumed. 
The revised debt version of the Fisher equation of exchange then  reduces to:

Total debt Md  =  PQ + (Ms+Mv)

As a first approximation  Md is very nearly  the country's  Domestic  Credit plus  its accumulated Current Account Deficit  (In the paper,  the accumulated Current Account Deficit is the total of all the  annual deficits since 1954).

Ms is the accumulated interest paid by the productive sector to the  investment sector as unearned income.

Ms is really the seigniorage of the modern debt economy that began with interest paid on unproductive debt by the English Crown to the directors of the Bank of England in 1694.   That debt and the associated introduction of  fiat currency (banknotes)  allowed the  Crown to avoid politically dangerous tax increases to pay for its war costs.   Ms broadly represents the "gap" so often referred to in  monetary reform literature.

In New Zealand, Ms has been increasing exponentially at the rate of  about 11.2% per year for decades whereas Md has been increasing 
exponentially  at 8.6% per year.

Ms is inherently inflationary because, leaving aside any productivity  changes, it means more and more  debt has to be used for the same  amount of production.  In practice the productive sector usually  borrows the extra debt each year to fund the unearned income and, by  and large,  passes on in its prices to consumers any change in its  resulting costs.

Mv is the infamous investment "bubble" that grows and decays during  each  business cycle.  When times are "good" the banks lend  extensively to investors directly on the assumption that next week's  investment sector prices will be higher than this week's prices.  The  banks do this because they increase their profit if they lend more.  

Mv bubbles are typically liquidated during recessions and the year or  two after they end.

In the revised Fisher equation, Md, PQ and Ms are readily available  from statistics, and that means the bubble Mv  can for the first  time,  be accurately quantified.

Click to see The new debt model for New Zealand 1979-2009.

The first and most relevant  feature of the model is that all the  curves are exponential.  To keep afloat, the debt economy is locked  into exponential growth of debt and GDP.

 

 The second  most relevant feature is that  the exponential for the  investment sector Ms (11.2%)  is much greater than that for  the  total debt Md (8.6%).  That means present and past monetary policy  necessarily produces a rapid transfer of wealth from the productive  sector to the investment sector. Wage and salary earners are  fundamentally disadvantaged relative to those with deposits in the  banking system who receive a "free-lunch" in the form of unearned  income merely because they have those deposits.  Producers get  ever  less while non-producers get more and more.  There is a large,  structural and on-going transfer of wealth taking place from the poor  to the rich in society.  In the present system that transfer in  wealth can only be offset through large-scale income redistribution.

The third most relevant feature is that the current financial  "architecture" is quite unsustainable. Economic "crashes" become  unavoidable as investment sector expectations literally drown the ability of the productive sector to satisfy them.

The model suggests the only way  to remedy that fundamental  contradiction (assuming we persist with the current system) is for  the investment sector to expand at the same rate as the productive  economy.

That in turn means that both the price and quantity of new debt have  to be managed by the government or the reserve bank .

Centuries of evidence show that private issue of debt for profit is  diametrically opposed to such price and quantity controls. Banks earn 
more by lending more.

The most recent and classic case is the "meltdown" in the US where a  whole raft of derivatives was  designed to allow unrestrained and 
irresponsible lending to patently uncreditworthy customers.  Such   "pass the parcel" transfers of toxic debt accentuated the underlying 
systemic risk instead of reducing it. On such grounds alone there is a  powerful case for public control of  the issue of new debt (and money in the form of electronic cash)  and  public control of deposit interest rates.

.........................................................

The debt model offers valuable insights into other areas of major  interest to economists.

First,  It provides a specific and rational definition of recessions and depressions.   A depression occurs when the change in the total  debt over time is less than what is needed to service the unearned  interest that has to be paid to the investment sector Ms plus any  increase in speculative investment Mv; that is, when there is no  provision for either inflation or growth.  A recession occurs when  the change in total debt over time is less than what is needed to  service the financial system costs, being the unearned interest that  has to be paid to the investment sector Ms, plus speculative  investment Mv, plus inflation.

Secondly,  New Zealand has borrowed ALL of its nominal GDP growth for  decades. The accumulated current account deficit is about NZ$100 
billion higher than it otherwise would have been, and savings and  wealth in the country about NZ$ 100 billion lower.  The paper introduces the concept of system liquidity, Mcd, being the GDP less  the accumulated current account deficit.   Mcd represents transaction  account balances plus earned savings. The paper shows Mcd is dangerously low in New Zealand and that there are few earned savings  left in the system.   Mcd, the debt actually used to produce domestic  goods and services, times its speed of circulation Vcd equals the  domestically produced  GDP.   Until quite recently  Vcd was  reasonably close to what V is thought to have been in the original  Fisher equation.   The level of earned savings is defined primarily  by the debt system mechanics and the current account deficit rather  than by individual savers.

Finally,  in the absence of tax or other incentives to encourage  traditional savings,  there is an inherent conflict of interest  between increasing productive  GDP output and households still  holding debt.  Economic efficiency will usually induce households to  retire expensive debt instead of saving.  In the debt model debt  retirement reduces economic output.

 

............................................................

The debt model does not, of itself, distinguish between "good" and  "bad" GDP but it recognises implicitly that new debt creation should  focus on productive activity.  To achieve this there is good reason  to reserve to the government the issue of new debt, with that debt  being spent into circulation in the form of investment in education,  health, research, infrastructure and business development.

Following  first use of new domestic debt by the government the  corresponding deposits would appear in the banking system from where the banks would on-lend it according to  monetary policy guidelines  published from time to time.

In its 78th annual report  (p137) the Bank for International  Settlements (BIS) wrote of the current turmoil in the world's  financial centres  "A powerful interaction between financial market  innovation, lax internal and external governance and easy global  monetary conditions over many years has led us to today's predicament."

Presently the financial system itself is structured to not only  allow, but to encourage those human and institutional failings to  which the BIS properly refers. Those failings are largely driven by  self interest and greed that are part of human nature. Since human  nature is unlikely to change, the world financial architecture needs  to be remodelled to keep sticky human fingers out of the global money pot.

Lowell Manning 5/7/09


 

Summaries of monetary reform papers by L.F. Manning published at http://www.integrateddevelopment.org.

 

NEW Capital is debt.

 

NEW Comments on the IMF (Benes and Kumhof) paper “The Chicago Plan Revisited”.

 

DNA of the debt-based economy.

General summary of all papers published.(Revised edition).

How to create stable financial systems in four complementary steps. (Revised edition).

How to introduce an e-money financed virtual minimum wage system in New Zealand. (Revised edition) .

How to introduce a guaranteed minimum income in New Zealand. (Revised edition).

Interest-bearing debt system and its economic impacts. (Revised edition).

Manifesto of 95 principles of the debt-based economy.

The Manning plan for permanent debt reduction in the national economy.

Missing links between growth, saving, deposits and GDP.

Savings Myth. (Revised edition).

Unified text of the manifesto of the debt-based economy.

Using a foreign transactions surcharge (FTS) to manage the exchange rate.

 

 

(The following items have not been revised. They show the historic development of the work. )

 

Financial system mechanics explained for the first time. “The Ripple Starts Here.”

Short summary of the paper The Ripple Starts Here.

Financial system mechanics: Power-point presentation. 

 


"Money is not the key that opens the gates of the market but the bolt that bars them."

Gesell, Silvio, The Natural Economic Order, revised English edition, Peter Owen, London 1958, page 228.


 

Creative Commons License

 

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Non-commercial-Share Alike 3.0 Licence.